Key Observations

  1. Real Boom (Green Box):
    • This period refers to historically robust population growth driven by organic economic factors. These could include:
      • Natural Population Growth: High birth rates or family sizes.
      • Economic Prosperity: Agricultural or industrial expansions providing stable economic opportunities.
      • Immigration Waves: Large-scale immigration, particularly during Canada’s nation-building era in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when the country actively sought settlers.
  2. Credit Boom (Red Box):
    • This period reflects recent growth that may be highly leveraged on debt-fueled economic conditions or targeted immigration policies to offset stagnation from lower natural birth rates and aging populations. Indicators include:
      • Urbanization and Real Estate Booms: Economic dependency on housing markets and infrastructure growth.
      • Monetary Policy: Low interest rates encourage borrowing, fueling population-linked investments like housing.
      • Policy-Driven Immigration: Aggressive immigration targets filling demographic gaps.
  3. Exponential Decline:
    • The trend line reflects a long-term decline in natural population growth rates despite periodic surges.
  4. Recent Spike (2024):
    • A sharp rise during the “Credit Boom” phase suggests a dependence on immigration to sustain population growth, a stark contrast to the organically driven “Real Boom.”

Implications

Real Boom vs. Credit Boom

  • Real Boom: Reflects a time when population growth was more sustainable and tied to long-term economic fundamentals.
  • Credit Boom: Growth heavily dependent on debt, policy intervention, and external migration rather than organic, internal factors.

Economic Vulnerabilities:

  • Credit Boom Fragility: A growth model reliant on credit expansion and immigration can be more vulnerable to global economic shifts, interest rate hikes, and real estate downturns.

Policy Reflection:

  • The shift from “Real” to “Credit” growth reflects broader structural changes in Canada’s economy, such as transitioning from manufacturing/agriculture to service and housing-driven economies.

Conclusion

The chart highlights how Canadian population growth evolved from fundamental, internally driven factors to reliance on external, policy-induced stimuli. It suggests potential instability in the modern growth model if economic or immigration policies falter.

Continue Reading

Join substack

Receive in depth regular articles and musings from Joseph