US Stock Valuations Have Reached Extreme Levels: A 95-Year Perspective.

In the ongoing debate about US stock market valuations, a striking chart from the Financial Times’ Daily Shot presents a compelling visualization of how extraordinary current market conditions are. By examining the ratio of non-financial market capitalization to corporate gross value-added from 1929 to 2024, we can see that today’s valuations have reached levels that raise essential questions about market sustainability.

The Historical Context

The journey began in 1929, requiring a little introduction to market historians. From the depths of the Great Depression through the post-war economic boom, the Cold War, the tech bubble, and into our modern era, this metric has served as a reliable indicator of market valuations. This measure is valuable because it compares market values to actual economic output, providing a more fundamental view than traditional P/E ratios.

The Monetary Wave: 1981-2024

Perhaps the most striking feature of the chart is what’s labelled as the “Monetary Wave” – a clear upward trend that began in 1981 and continues through 2024. This period coincides with several significant developments in monetary policy and market structure:

– The beginning of the great bull market under Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker
– A multi-decade decline in interest rates
– The rise of modern financial markets and innovative financial products
– The emergence of the digital economy
– The era of quantitative easing and unprecedented monetary policy

Current Valuations in Perspective

The chart’s logarithmic scale helps us understand how extreme current valuations are. The metric has pushed above a critical threshold (marked by a red line) that has historically signalled significant overvaluation. What’s particularly noteworthy is that these levels exceed even those seen during other historically expensive periods.

This raises several critical questions:
– Are we witnessing a new normal in valuations, supported by structural economic changes?
– Have monetary policies fundamentally altered the relationship between market values and economic output?
– What might trigger a reversion to historical means, and what would that look like?

Looking Forward

While history suggests that extreme valuations rarely persist indefinitely, it’s crucial to understand that historical patterns don’t always predict future outcomes. The modern market environment includes several unique factors:

1. The dominance of technology companies with different value-creation models
2. Global monetary policies that have fundamentally altered the investment landscape
3. Changes in corporate structure and capital allocation
4. The rise of passive investing and its impact on market dynamics

Implications for Investors

The current valuation landscape suggests several considerations for market participants:

1. The importance of maintaining a disciplined investment approach
2. The potential need for broader diversification strategies
3. The value of understanding historical context while recognizing modern market dynamics
4. The need to prepare for potentially lower future returns

Conclusion

The 95-year perspective this data provides is a powerful reminder of the markets’ cyclical nature and current valuations’ extraordinary nature. While this doesn’t necessarily predict imminent market corrections, it does suggest that investors should approach current market levels with a clear understanding of historical context and a thoughtful approach to risk management.

For investors and market observers, this data doesn’t just represent numbers on a chart – it tells the story of nearly a century of market history. It hints at the challenges and opportunities that may lie ahead in navigating what appears to be historically uncharted territory.

Join substack

Receive in depth regular articles and musings from Joseph